SBC said:
A consistent scrutiny should be applied, regardless of a person's belief or disbelief. And that is my point. NOBODY should start judging from a presupposition. Same goes for an atheist as for a Christian.
I agree - if I understand what you mean by "consistent scrutiny". The truth of the matter is that we all start from presuppositions. If we didn't have axioms, we wouldn't able to draw conclusions.
What I find striking is that Fundy Atheists have the same attitude as the Hard Core Baptists I grew up with. It was that attitude that first caused me to question, then leave them. If I leave one group because of an attitude, I am not about to join another with the same attitude. BTW, those same GARBC Baptists basically shun me and consider me to be an apostate bound for Hell.
What I find strange is that while claiming that there is no Truth, they believe that they alone have the Truth. In other words, if a person has any ability to think, the only conclusion they can come to is to agree with atheists. If one concludes that there is a God, weeeellllll... that is evidence in itself that they are incapable of rational thought. Do Baptists have the same line of thinking? Yep. If you are going to climb into that boat with them, that is your problem.
I am no more interested in hearing Fundy Atheists preach and lecture at me than I am some preacher from the God Almighty Righteous Baptist Church. I am more than willing to exchange ideas with anyone. The whole reason I am on this board is to share ideas with others and to get a broader idea what others are thinking.